Google <\/a> has completed a controversial take-over of the health division of its UK AI acquisition<\/a>, DeepMind.<\/p>\n The personnel move had been delayed as National Health Service <\/a> (NHS) trusts considered whether to shift their existing DeepMind contracts \u2014 some for a clinical task management app, others involving predictive health AI research \u2014 to Google.<\/p>\n In a blog post <\/a>yesterday Dr Dominic King, formerly of DeepMind (and the NHS), now UK site lead at Google Health, confirmed the transfer, writing: \u201cIt\u2019s clear that a transition like this<\/a> takes time. Health data is sensitive, and we gave proper time and care to make sure that we had the full consent and cooperation of our partners. This included giving them the time to ask questions and fully understand our plans and to choose whether to continue our partnerships. As has always been the case, our partners are in full control of all patient data and we will only use patient data to help improve care, under their oversight and instructions.\u201d<\/p>\n The Royal Free NHS Trust<\/a>, Taunton & Somerset NHS Foundation Trust<\/a>, Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust<\/a>, Moorfields Eye Hospital NHS Foundation Trust<\/a> and University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust<\/a> all put out statements yesterday confirming they have moved their contractual arrangements to Google.<\/p>\n In the case of the Royal Free, patients\u2019 Streams data is moving to the Google Cloud Platform infrastructure to support expanding use of the app which surfaces alerts for a kidney condition to another of its hospitals (Barnet Hospital).<\/p>\n One NHS trust, Yeovil District Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, has not signed a new contract \u2014 and says it had never deployed Streams, suggesting it had not found a satisfactory way to integrate the app with its existing ways of working \u2014 instead taking the decision to terminate the arrangement. Though it\u2019s leaving the door open to future health service provision from Google.<\/p>\n A spokeswoman for Yeovil hospital sent us this statement:<\/p>\n We began our relationship with DeepMind in 2017 and since then have been determining what part the Streams application could play in clinical decision making here at Yeovil Hospital.<\/p>\n The app was never operationalised, and no patient data was processed.<\/p>\n What\u2019s key for us as a hospital, when it comes to considering the implementation of any new piece of technology, is whether it improves the effectiveness and safety of patient care and how it tessellates with existing ways of working. Working with the DeepMind <\/a> team, we found that Streams is not necessary for our organisation at the current time.<\/p>\n Whilst our contractual relationship has ended, we will remain an anchor partner of Google Health so will continue to be part of conversations about emerging technology which may be of benefit to our patients and our clinician in the future.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n The hand-off of DeepMind Health to Google, which was announced just over a year ago<\/a>, means the tech giant is now directly providing software services to a number of NHS trusts that had signed contracts with DeepMind for Streams; as well as taking over several AI research partnerships that involve the use of NHS patients\u2019 data to try to develop predictive diagnostic models using AI technology.<\/p>\n DeepMind \u2014 which kicked off its health efforts by signing an agreement with the Royal Free NHS Trust in 2015, going on to publicly announce the health division in spring 2016 \u2014 said last year<\/a> its future focus would be as a \u201cresearch organisation\u201d.<\/p>\n As recently as this July<\/a> DeepMind was also touting a predictive healthcare research \u201cbreakthrough\u201d \u2014 announcing it had trained a deep learning model for continuously predicting the future likelihood of a patient developing a life-threatening condition called acute kidney injury. (Though the AI is trained on heavily gender-skewed data from the US department of Veteran Affairs.)<\/p>\n Yet it\u2019s now become clear that it\u2019s handed off several of its key NHS research partnerships to Google Health as part of the Streams transfer.<\/p>\n In its statement<\/a> about the move yesterday, UCLH writes that \u201cit was proposed\u201d that its DeepMind research partnership \u2014 which is related to radiotherapy treatment for patients with head and neck cancer \u2014 be transferred to Google Health, saying this will enable it to \u201cmake use of Google\u2019s scale and experience to deliver potential breakthroughs to patients more rapidly\u201d.<\/p>\n \u201cWe will retain control over the anonymised data and remain responsible for deciding how it is used,\u201d it adds. \u201cThe anonymised data is encrypted and only accessible to a limited number of researchers who are working on this project with UCLH\u2019s permission. Access to the data will only be granted for officially approved research purposes and will be automatically audited and logged.\u201d<\/p>\n It\u2019s worth pointing out that the notion of \u201canonymised\u201d high dimension health data should be treated with a healthy degree of scepticism<\/a> \u2014 given the risk of re-identification.<\/p>\n Moorfields <\/a>also identifies Google\u2019s \u201cresources\u201d as the incentive for agreeing for its eye-scan related research partnership to be handed off, writing: \u201cThis updated partnership will allow us to draw on Google\u2019s resources and expertise to extend the benefits of innovations that AI offers to more of our clinicians and patients.\u201d<\/p>\n Quite where this leaves DeepMind\u2019s ambitions to \u201clead the way in fundamental research applying AI to important science and medical research questions, in collaboration with academic partners, to accelerate scientific progress for the benefit of everyone\u201d, as it put it last year<\/a> \u2014 when it characterized the hand-off to Google Health as all about \u2018scaling Streams\u2019 \u2014 remains to be seen.<\/p>\n We\u2019ve reached out to DeepMind for comment on that. Update: <\/strong>The company told us it is now purely focused on fundamental science research areas, which includes medical questions, rather than applied healthcare \u2014 citing its research into protein folding<\/a> as an example. Whereas it said Moorfields and UCLH are interested in the translation of research into applicable technologies beyond fundamental research, making Google Health a better fit.<\/p>\n Co-founder Mustafa Suleyman, who\u2019s been taking a leave of absence from the company, tweeted yesterday to congratulate the Google Health team.<\/p>\n